For this article, I will try to help you make better informed decisions when choosing assembly lubes and lubricants. First, do you need engine assembly lubes at all? As a physicist-motorhead who has built and destroyed his share of engines, I think so. When metal-to-metal contact occurs in an engine, localized overheating is created. This can wipe a bearing almost instantly. There are other ares in an engine (e.g., push rod tips, rocker arms) that don't receive lubricant until a few seconds after the engine has been running and oil spray is established.
As far as lubrication goes, any reasonable amount of oil will protect surfaces by preventing metal-to-metal contact if it contains sufficient Zinc dithiophosphate (ZDP). Thinner oils can rapidly run off the surfaces they are intended to protect. Heavier oils run off more slowly, so they are more effective if the engine is to be stored before use. Today's motorcycle oils don't contain sufficient (ZDP) to protect parts which haven't yet been broken in.
The ultimate, of course, is grease. Grease is simply oil which is contained in a waxy, soap substrate. The substrate keeps the oil from running away until it is needed. When operating temperatures rise, the substrate melts, and the oil flows to the component to do its job.
Don't use grease on every part of the engine because it is so stiff that it will make that first start difficult. Use grease only where oil flow and surface protection is less than desirable such as:
- Drive gears,
- Camshaft gear drives,
- Drive gears
- Flat tappet cams and lifters
- Pushrod tips
- Rocker arm and valve stem tips.
Those particles floating around in the engine make me nervous. What if one of them block an oil feed hole? One doesn't have to gamble, since most greases out there dissolve in oil. Be sure to ask your supplier that direct question, and make sure that the supplier understands what you asking!!
If the engine will be fired up and broken in immediately, then heavy oil, STP, or a mixture of heavy oil and STP (with adequate ZDP) will protection. Before engine assembly lubes were invented, I used a mixture of STP and SAE 30 grade oil plus added ZDP as an engine assembly lube. Back then I still used grease on flat tappet cams and lifters.
The problem with heavy oils and STP is they weren't formulated to be engine assembly lubes. Shell Rotella, for example, contains less than 0.01% weight zinc. I like to see at least 0.02% zinc for initial startup. They will work, but chemically engineered engine assembly lubes contain ZDP chemistry for extreme pressure (EP) protection and rust inhibitors to prevent rusting of vital components. Rust on a valve spring can significantly affect its elastic limit or even cause it to break under extreme circumstances. Tackifier agents are also used in assembly lubes to help the oil cling to the surface to be protected longer.
None of the above will protect an engine if it is put together dirty. I think I mentioned a few times before to work in a clean environment, but any speck of material which is harder than cast aluminum, or iron and larger than the bearing clearances can easily destroy the perfect engine build. Engine components can't be cleaned too much before putting the engine together. I clean my block in soap and water and then spray them down with WD-40 in hopes of removing all potentially dangerous particles which might be embedded in the porous cast aluminum. I clean lifters and rocker arms in solvent to remove machining debris, blow them dry, and then soak them in break-in oil.
I've also begun using fluids on bolts which are to be torqued. Using a lubricant on a bolt does two things. First, lubricating the threads means the bolt will pull down more evenly with less stiction. Secondly, a lubricated set of threads means a bolt will be pulled down tighter at the same torque wrench reading, because friction between the threads has been significantly reduced.
I should also comment about GM E.O.S. As a lubricant supplement. E.O.S. Was originally designed to add more ZDP and other additives to '60s design oils which weren't very heavily compound. Oils of today have two to three times the additive content of '60s oils, with the exception of ZDP. The only thing they need to be more effective is additional ZDP, rust inhibitors, and tackifiers. I'm not certain E.O.S. Is the best answer for today's motorcycle engines and oils.
This brings up the subject of brand marketing. We all experience it everyday, and it upsets an old technical guy like myself. Just because your grandfather ran a specific brand of oil that was great once upon a time doesn't guarantee that it is great now.